Be in the conversation before the job description is written.
Almost everyone running a senior search underestimates how few of the roles they'd actually want will ever appear on a public job board. They scroll LinkedIn, set up alerts, and apply into the same queue as four hundred other people. The roles they're looking for are moving — they're just moving through a different channel, one that rewards being known by the right people three months earlier rather than being faster on the apply button. This piece is about that channel, and how to work it without becoming the person your network starts to dread hearing from.
What "the hidden job market" actually means
"Hidden" is a slightly dramatic word for something fairly mundane. Most senior roles get filled through one of three routes long before they ever hit a public board: an internal move, a trusted referral from someone the hiring manager already knows, or the hiring manager remembering a specific person from an earlier conversation and picking up the phone. The job description, where it exists, is often written after the conversation has already started — sometimes around the person the company wants to hire.
The further up the seniority ladder, the more pronounced this gets. Below mid-management, public boards are still the dominant route. At director level and above, in most sectors, the share of roles that ever appear publicly drops sharply — and the ones that do are frequently formalities, posted to satisfy a process while the preferred candidate is already in late-stage conversation.
Why this matters more the more senior you are
Three things tend to be true of senior searches. There are fewer genuinely matching roles in any given quarter; the search cycle is longer (often six to nine months from first conversation to start date); and the public-applicant route puts you in a queue where your CV is competing on paper against people the hiring manager already knows by name.
Working only the visible market in those conditions is not a strategy — it is a way to wait. The hidden market is slower to start and harder to measure, but it converts at a much higher rate per conversation, and the conversations it produces tend to be about better-fitting roles. Most of the senior candidates we work with end up landing through a route that started with a conversation, not a submission.
The mindset shift: from applications to shortlists
The single most useful reframe is to stop thinking about "applying for jobs" and start thinking about "being on the shortlist of people a hiring manager calls when something opens". The work changes shape. You are no longer optimising a CV to clear an ATS; you are becoming credibly known to a small number of people, in a small number of organisations, for a specific kind of work.
This is slower, quieter, and feels less productive — there is no satisfying "applied" button to click. But the conversion rate is in a different league. One well-run coffee with the right person is worth a hundred unread applications, and you can have one of those conversations most weeks.
Build a target list of 25–40 organisations, not 200
The most common mistake is a target list that is too long to work. Two hundred companies is a spreadsheet, not a strategy. Twenty-five to forty is small enough that you can hold the context, follow what is happening at each one, and have a sensible answer ready when one of them comes up in conversation.
Pick them deliberately, against four filters:
- Sector fit — where your experience genuinely transfers, not where it could in theory.
- Stage and shape — size, ownership model and growth profile that match the kind of role you want next.
- Geography — the locations you can actually work from, including any honest line on hybrid expectations.
- People you'd want to work for — the underrated filter. If you don't respect the leadership team, neither will the work.
Keep the list live. Add a column for what is happening at each one — funding rounds, leadership moves, restructures, new product lines — because these are the natural openings for a relevant message. Cull the ones that drop off your radar after three months; the discipline of pruning matters more than the discipline of adding.
Map the people inside each target who matter
For each organisation on the list, write down three or four names: the hiring manager for the role you'd want, the manager's manager (often the person who actually approves the hire), the function head you would report to, and one or two peers at your level who might either become colleagues or have moved on by the time a role opens. Don't try to cover the whole org chart — depth in a few places beats breadth across the lot.
Use LinkedIn for the structural picture, but read around it. Earnings calls, press releases, sector publications, conference speaker lists and the occasional podcast tell you what these people are actually working on, in their own words. That is the raw material for a first message that doesn't sound generic.
How to make first contact without spamming
The order of preference is unambiguous: warm intro, then warm-ish touchpoint (a former colleague, a shared conference, a comment thread you've been part of), then cold message. The cold message works occasionally; the warm intro works most of the time. Ask the people who know you well, by name, for specific introductions to specific people — not for a general "let me know if you hear of anything", which puts the work onto them and produces almost nothing.
A warm intro request that actually gets sent
Hi Sam — I'm looking at a small number of organisations for my next move, and one of them is Northwind. I noticed you worked with Priya Shah there until last year. If you're comfortable with it, would you be willing to introduce us? Happy to send a short blurb you can forward. No pressure either way, and either answer is fine.
A cold message that doesn't feel cold
Hi Priya — I lead operations for a mid-market manufacturer and I've been following Northwind since the Series C; the way you've described the move from regional to national distribution is the cleanest version of that story I've seen written down. I'm starting to look at what's next over the next six to nine months and would value a 25-minute conversation about how you're thinking about the operations build — no agenda beyond that. Happy to share my CV if useful.
Three things make these work: a specific reason for messaging this person (not a copy-and-paste), an honest framing of where you are (not pretending to be casually curious when you're actively looking), and a small, low-cost ask (a conversation, not a job). What to avoid: AI-slop openers ("I hope this finds you well"), flattery without substance, attaching a CV to a first cold message, and any version of "I'd love to pick your brain".
Running the 25-minute exploratory conversation
You asked for 25 minutes; honour it. Have a short shape in mind and let it breathe. A sensible structure:
- Two minutes: thank them, restate the specific reason you wanted to talk to them, and the time budget.
- Eight minutes: ask about their work — what they're focused on this quarter, what is harder than people outside assume, where they think the function or sector is heading.
- Eight minutes: share, briefly and concretely, what you do and what you're looking for next. One sentence of background, two or three results, and the kind of role and sector you're focused on. Resist the urge to recite your CV.
- Five minutes: ask the two questions that matter — "Given what I've described, who else in your network would it be most useful for me to speak with?" and "Is it OK if I keep you posted as I progress?". End on time.
Follow up the same day with a short, specific note — one paragraph, mentioning something they said you'll act on, and any promised introductions. Then put a calendar reminder to send them a brief update every six to eight weeks. Most senior hires happen on the second or third contact, often months after the first conversation, and they tend to go to whichever credible candidate was most recently on the hiring manager's mind.
The weekly discipline that makes this work
The reason most people abandon this approach is not that it doesn't work — it's that it doesn't reward you weekly. The fix is to define the inputs you can control and ignore the outputs you can't, for a defined period.
A modest, sustainable weekly rhythm:
- Three to five new, specific outreach messages.
- Three to five follow-ups to people already in conversation.
- One genuinely useful piece of work — a short observation post, a comment on someone's article, a forwarded resource — so you have a reason to be visible without sounding like you're job-hunting in public.
- A 30-minute weekly review of the target list and pipeline — what moved, what stalled, who to chase, what to cull.
Track the pipeline the way a salesperson would: targets, first contacts, conversations held, follow-ups pending, intros made. "Number of applications sent" is the wrong KPI here and will quietly pull you back into the visible market if you let it.
How Launchpad supports this
Inside Launchpad, this is built into the day-to-day work rather than parked as a separate exercise. The Application Tracker is designed to hold the target list, conversations and follow-ups as a single pipeline — not just submitted applications — so you can see what is actually moving. The Proposition module gives you the short, concrete version of who you are and what you're looking for next, so the exploratory conversations have something specific to land on.
Cara, our virtual coach, will draft and pressure-test outreach before it goes out and help you prepare for the conversations themselves. Your ImaginativeHR coach is in the loop for the harder judgement calls — who to ask for an introduction and when, when to push a conversation forward, when to wait, and how to read what is actually going on inside a target organisation. The combination is the point: a clear method, a tool that keeps the pipeline honest, and a coach who has seen the pattern before.
If you'd like to see how this fits alongside the rest of a senior transition, we're happy to walk through the platform with you and your team. Get in touch.








